Why are so many silmarillion characters portrayed as gay

Bisexuals only account for 28% LGBTQ characters on shows, close to half of the real numbers (1/3 for gen z) they may actually be proportionate or even slightly underrepresented as a whole while lesbian gay and trans people all appear even further overrepresented than the data would initially suggest. This is also done in fandom. If you’re familiar with The Silmarillion, the prequel to The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit, then you’re familiar with Fingon.

Fingon is a character in The Silmarillion who is often portrayed by the fandom as a black elf with box braids. The Silmarillion is J.R.R. Tolkien’s work in which his Christian upbringing and influence can be seen through the story and the characters. From the song that brings Arda to life to Morgoth’s fall, the book is part of an original pre-history to Middle-Earth and an allegory to Christian’s mythology. At the same time the Hobbit and LOTR are not sexual books.

Love in the series is familial, platonic, and that of friends and family. One of the problems of modernity is trying to impose modern ideas on the past. There's plenty of gay and lesbian characters in other fantasy series; just certainly not in any of Tolkien's work. In The Silmarillion ̧ there are many levels and forms of power wielded by characters in different ways.

The chief instruments of power are the Valar, immortal and extremely powerful spirits sent by Ilúvatar to create and govern the world. Eight of the Valar have the most power and importance; five of these are male, and three are female. I love the Lord of the Rings. There are 20 things that are relevant to the story before his sexuality.

Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options Pottery Barn.

Do sam and frodo kiss in the books

Rowling, her books, and attendant phenomena. I happen to know that the desire for it leads to the act of viewing it. The tale is there not to hide, but to show: if it show nothing at your window, do not open your door to it; leave it out in the cold. I don't personally have an issue with them forcing black people into the lore, as long as the show doesn't become all about why are so many silmarillion characters portrayed as gay.

I see Turin as a distillation of the human condition from a Judaeo-Christian perspective, bearing in mind Tolkien was a devout Catholic. Worse still, he murdered Brandir who reported the death of Niniel; adding insult to injury he slandered Brandir before the people and accused him of inventing Glaurung's lies. I think the Elves may be asexual - they live for such a long time that building relationships simply on animalistic desires would create rifts between 'exes'.

It was a deep, enduring, powerful friendship, something amazing to both watch and read. Too many ignorant people nowadays simply look at his works through their own hypersexualised modern lenses and interpret them in ways unintended by the author. November 16, at pm. They tend to be more plot oriented in the sense that there is a goal and the main character strives to overcome obstacles to achieve that goal.

This is done intentionally; the narratological perspective is a large part of what drives the mystery in each book along and of Ms. That's a good argument, although as I recall Elrond's demands of Aragorn are very high as well. If one is dealing with larger-than-life material — which is what the epic truly involves — there is comparatively little space for dealing with the more mundane and private aspects of human existence, and if sexuality takes a backseat, so does its variants.

It has gay romance between main characters, which builds up slowly and then still looks good in further books when it becomes a strong relationship. He never married or seemed to be attracted to anyone did he? Boybatons 9. In my opinion the sexual component in the Middle-Earth romances is implied. Sturgis said the young woman speaking to Ms. People have to examine their own attitudes.

Squirrelwithabouzouki has hit the nail right on the head; some people will believe whatever they like, regardless of the evidence. Hear hear!

Albus fell in love with a brilliant young man, a love that was unrequited and which ended in the tragic death of his younger sister. Or at least, the myths that I have read.

Thoughts on Queer characters in fantasy | A Phuulish Fellow

Rowling what she meant in her stories is insulting. Both characters are also heterosexual in all other settings, so this bout of homosexual activity is likely more experimentation than full-blown bisexuality. Most people tend to agree that Bilbo Baggins is asexual and aromantic as well